Glenville Detachment of the State Police and Gilmer County Officials back losing side of Supreme Court Case, as reported in the West Virginia Record!!

West Virginia Record

Supreme Court affirms Gilmer Co. decision

Benjamin

Benjamin

CHARLESTON – Because the intentions in his will were clear enough, the state Supreme Court has ruled a Gilmer County woman may continue to reside in the home she shared with her former companion.

In a 4-1 decision, the court affirmed the ruling Gilmer Circuit Judge Jack Alsop made in August 2012 granting summary judgment to Ruth Mitchell in a suit to quiet title brought by the estate and heirs of Willard Cottrill.

In a memorandum opinion issued Oct. 18, two days shy of the third anniversary of Cottrill, 73, dying suddenly and under suspicious circumstances, the court said the effort by the estate’s executor, Michael Murphy, Cottrill’s son-in-law, and the heirs to eject Mitchell from the modular home she shared with Cottrill on his 42-acre property in Linn is “wholly inconsistent,” with his last will and testament.

Memorandum opinions are issued by the court in cases that present no new issues of law and would not be aided by oral argument. Chief Justice Brent Benjamin cast the dissenting vote.

According to court records, Cottrill’s will was admitted into probate on Nov. 5, 2010. In it, he directed that a residence be provided for Mitchell “for so long as she chooses to reside, with this provision becoming void should she at any time choose or need to live elsewhere.”

Cottrill also specified that Mitchell’s “residency shall not preclude divestiture of the property by my heirs, and is not intended to establish a life tenancy.” Furthermore, he “direct[ed] that income from the rental units on my property be used for taxes and upkeep of the remainder of the property including the unit occupied by Ruth Mitchell, and the parcel referenced in the above provision.”

On June 17, 2011, Murphy, along with his wife, Venita, and her brothers Mark and Alan Cottrill, residents of Syracuse, N.Y., filed suit seeking an order to compel Mitchell to “vacate the premises.”

However, on Aug. 21, 2012, the eve of a trial date in the case, Alsop granted Mitchell’s motion for summary judgment recognizing, as Cottrill specified in his will, she had a right to reside on the property so long as she desired.

In affirming Alsop’s decision, the court clarified that Mitchell’s residence is no way construed to be a life estate or tenancy. Regardless, ordering her out of the dwelling she’s called home for the last decade would go against Cottrill’s express wishes.

“The relief [the estate and the heirs] sought beyond clear title – this is, ejectment – is wholly inconsistent with [Cottrill’s] directive that [Mitchell] be provided a residence,” the court said.

“Inasmuch as the circuit court was called upon to construe Mr. Cottrill’s will in this action to quiet title, it appropriately followed the tenant of this Court: ‘The cardinal principle in construing a will is to ascertain the intent of the testator as expressed in the wills and codicils, giving consideration to the surrounding circumstances.’”

The estate, and the heirs were represented by Staci N. Criswell with Dinsmore and Shohl. Mitchell was defended by Gassaway attorney Dan Grindo.

West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals case number 12-1213
Gilmer Circuit Court case number 11-C-20

2 comments

  1. revenge of the ghost wolf 10
    gilmer co wv free press 9
    calpatty press 6
    bree wolfe 6
    justin feagin 5
    call patty press west virginia 4
    gilmer county free press west virginia 4
    justin feagin glenville state 4
    jim fealy oil and gas lobbyist 4
    nasia butcher glenville wv 4
    cal patty press 4
    gilmer free press 3
    high school scandal 3
    steve canterbury wv 3
    revenge of the ghost wolf wv 3
    hannah demarino 3
    hannah demarino,glenville wv 3
    sarah rutherford highschool teacher 2
    james ware wv arrest 2
    gilmer county lone wolf 2
    bobby duvall,glenville wv 2
    ike morris’ well diggers ball, glenville, wv 2
    lizzy and lexy butcher nude pics 2
    dr. william k simmons glenville state college 2
    gilmer co wv 2
    sarah rutterford. glenville, wv 2
    sexy girl sucking cock 2
    gilmerfree press.com 2
    women forced to have sex 2
    cowpatty news gilmer co 2
    doug cotrill ghost wolf 2
    mieke wilma nackt 2
    doug morris glenville wv 2
    lesbian kid porn 2
    tygart valley regional jail mugshots 2
    gilmerfreepress 2
    incest is best 2
    gilmer county sex scandal 2
    butcher bitches lexi lizzy 2
    tygart valley regional jail inmate mugshots 2
    hess of gilmer county 2
    pics.of.girls.naked.in.roane.county.wv 1
    sarah rutherford 1
    watch free carssia montgomery she-la full video 1
    sarah rutherford wv 1
    shelley morris demarino 1
    spike maynard, cocaine 1
    calpaddypress 1
    wilkie perez football 1
    bobs sex 1
    phil reale hearing with under cover police woman 1
    doctor kenneth seen, spencer wv charged 1
    steve canterbury being sued ran wv jails 1
    free full fucking and drunk porn in richwood w.v 1
    doug starcher calhoun county wv 1
    donald ray brown mugshot wv 1
    rape forced sex 1
    gilmer co. wv free press 1
    hannah sue dimarino 1
    first oil and gas well in gilmer cop wv 1
    http://www.revengeoftheghostwolf.com 1
    crystal metz glenville wv 1
    sexy child porn 1
    lizzie butcher lexi butcher 1
    ike morris glenville 1
    teacher fucks football coach 1
    east county party sluts naked 1
    bob henry baber and sarah rutherford 1
    cum on bitch 1
    gerry hough, glenville, wv 1
    longest misdemeanor case ever record us history 1
    rape 1
    inmates fucking mci norfolk 1
    glenville state college party school 1
    gilmer county wv waco oil 1
    brotherhood of death society 1
    «peak-a-boo» 1
    shelly de marino glenville, wv 1
    gilmer county free press wv 1
    corruption in wv 1
    corruption of wv state troopers 1
    ed broome glenville wv complaints 1
    concerned citizens free press 1
    justin feagins 1
    dr. kenneth seen, spencer, wv sons 1
    lewis county pussy 1
    sarah ann rutherford wv trial 1
    kelli nicole 1
    salwa from buckwild naked 1
    ike morris gilmer county wv corruption 1
    gilmer county wv corruption 1
    girls basketball coach duvall, glenville 1
    lexi butcher, glenville, wv 1
    demarino 1
    watkins judicial conduct trisl 1
    calpatty 1
    ike morris, wv 1
    deaths in wv ikes fork girk named sarah 1
    wilkie perez rape 1
    carissa hads 1
    banging bitches 1
    glenville state secret 7 blogs 1
    calpattypress.com 1
    revenge ofthe ghostwolf 1
    gilmer county radio stations 1
    butcher sisters glenville wv sex video 1
    hannah minney porn 1
    exposed naked girls 1
    gchs pussy 1
    butcher bitches glenville 1
    gilmer county west virginia valerie white arrested 1
    girls gone wild in gilmer county wv 1
    albert woofter park parkersburg 1
    steve canterbury charleston, wv facebook 1
    how to press charges against informant in va for enabling stalking 1
    turn coat butcher 1
    phil reale prostitution 1
    how should jud graft and corruption be handled in the courts in california 1
    judge facemire 1
    highschool scandal 1
    calhoun county wv 1
    wv law-if the county commissioners keep denying to put administrator out of his duty, can the other heirs take it before a judge? 1
    glenville wv scandal newspaper 1
    judge bandy corruption 1
    dr kenneth seen 1
    judge facemire in wv 1
    butcher bitches 1
    phil reale prostitution ring 1
    dan bingman tv 1
    ike morris glenville west virginia 1
    phil reale + wv mugshot 1
    butcher bitches gilmer 1
    revenge of the ghost wolf gilmer county 1
    lucy goes lunatic 1
    murder taylor county wv 1
    dr. daniel demarino. glenville, wv 1
    gila sex 1
    lexy butcher nude 1
    gilmore county free press 1
    free press drug dealing jordan morris 1
    betty jo martin 1
    stacy ray adkins glenville wv 1
    searching 4 a guy dick 1
    lexy love 1
    glenville state justin feagin 1
    12to15 years gay xxx sex videos 1
    student dragged in glenville, wv 1
    i l morris glenville 1
    phil reale prostitute charleston wv 1
    investigator for the secretary of states office in wv 1
    lucy kite hot 1
    teresa tarr wv 1
    histoey of elbert a woofter of bridgeport, wv ? 1
    +willyo smith 1
    what is a 13f felony charge wv 1
    gilmer county girls gone wild 1
    bree wolfe breasts 1
    conner ferguson glenville 1
    “doug morris rape 1
    rape nude 1
    jordan morris rape 1
    girl almost unconscious 1
    glenville free press 1
    husk family in calhoun county 1
    glenville state college rape testimony 1

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s